Jump to: navigation, search

Obsolete:IPAv3 testing AD trust

(Redirected from IPAv3 testing AD trust)

Obsolete Documentation

Please note that this content was marked as obsolete. We left the content here for study and archaeological purposes.

Please check our Documentation for a recent list of topics.

See up-to-date article Active Directory trust setup.

Testing trust between FreeIPA and AD

Please note that this page is in a draft stage and will change regularly as new features are added to FreeIPA.

NOTE: An updated howtois now available here

Install FreeIPA

The easiest way is to configure the freeipa nightly devel repository on a fully updated Fedora 17 box. Please note that this repository will always contain the very latest bits but may also be more unstable.

For Fedora 18 you need to enable updates and updates-testing repositories and you *don't* need to use nightly devel repository since everything is available in Fedora 18 already.

List of required package versions:

  • 389-ds-base: at least Earlier versions do not work with FreeIPA.
  • samba4: For FreeIPAv3 beta2 at least samba4 4.0.0beta2 is required, built with --without-ad-dc and --with-system-mitkrb5 options. Samba4 4.0.0beta2 has changed an API that FreeIPA cross-realm trust support is relying on, thus the requirement. Any samba4 versions before samba4 4.0.0beta1 also do not have proper MIT krb5 support.
  • If SELinux is in use, policy equal or greater then version 3.10.0-134.fc17 should be used.
  • MIT krb5 1.10 is required (krb5 1.10.2 or later is required)

Run ipa-server-install with --setup-dns and you favourite options to setup an FreeIPA server. It is preferred to use the DNS server of FreeIPA, otherwise a couple of settings must be added manually to the external DNS server.

If there is a DNS server which can route DNS traffic between the FreeIPA and AD domain this sould be used as forwarder with the option '--forwarder=ip.address'. If there is no such server alternatives are discussed in the following section.

Please do not forget to adjust the firewall settings as recommended by ipa-server-install.

Setting up Active Directory domain for testing purposes

Please follow article Setting up Active Directory domain for testing purposes

Check DNS

Is is important the both domains, FreeIPA and AD, can resolve names and especially service records of the other domain. Please add the needed configurations and test e.g. with

  • dig SRV _ldap._tcp.ipa.domain
  • dig SRV _ldap._tcp.ad.domain

If DNS fails against the AD domain you can try to add a special configuration to your named.conf.

Adding a conditional forwarder on the FreeIPA side

If FreeIPA is configured with DNS, you can use following command:

ipa dnszone-add ad.domain --name-server=$AD_DC --admin-email="hostmaster@ad.domain" --force --forwarder=$AD_DC_IP --forward-policy=only

alternatively you can define it manually in named.conf:

 zone "ad.domain" IN {
   type forward;
   forwarders { ip-address.of-one-or-more.ad.domain_controllers; };
   forward only;

As result, the FreeIPA DNS server will send all DNS request for the domain ad.domain to the specified forwarders.

Adding a conditional forwarder on the AD side

If DNS resolution does not work on the AS side, e.g. 'ping server.ipa.domain' does not work on the command prompt a conditional forwarder can be added to the AD DNS.

  • Open Start->Administrative Tools->DNS
  • make a right-click on 'Conditional Forwarders' in the left column of the window
  • select 'New Conditional Forwarder...'
  • add the DNS domain name of your FreeIPA domain name and the IP adresses of one or more DNS servers of your FreeIPA domain

You can also check out this video on how to set up the forwarders via the Windows GUI.

To test the new configuration you can try to ping your FreeIPA server again. It might be necessary to call 'ipconfig /flushdns' to removed any cached results.

Alternatively you can use command line utility dnscmd to configure the forwarder:

  • Open Start -> Command Prompt
  • Enter: dnscmd /ZoneAdd FreeIPA.Domain /Forwarder IP.AD.DR.ESS

The command should report that zone FreeIPA.Domain was successfully added.

Adding a common forwarder

As an alternative to add conditional forwarders to the configuration of the FreeIPA and AD servers a common forwarder can be used which routes the DNS request between the different domains. If there are more than two domains this might be the preferred solution because otherwise each domain controller needs to know the DNS servers of all other domains.

One way to create a common forwarder is to run dnsmasq on a separate server/VM like

 dnsmasq --no-dhcp-interface=eth0,eth1 --server=/ipa.domain/ - -server=/ad.domain/

DHCP is not needed so all interfaces on the server should be listed in '--no-dhcp-interface'. If you want to monitor the DNS traffic you can add '-d -q' so that dnsmasq runs in the foreground and prints debugging messages.

This server/VM now can be used as the default forwarder on the FreeIPA and AD servers.

Prepare FreeIPA server for trusts

Please note that currently SELinux denies winbind to access the Kerberos credential file of the smbd (https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=828619). Until there is an updated SELinux policy available SELinux should be set into the permissive more by calling 'setenforce 0'.

Call 'kinit admin' and call 'ipa-adtrust-install -p directory_manager_password' to create all the needed objects in the FreeIPA server.

Please set 'dns_lookup_kdc = true' in /etc/krb5.conf (https://fedorahosted.org/freeipa/ticket/2515).

ipa-adtrust-install configures new services and extended operations on the FreeIPA directory server. To make sure everything is started properly you can call 'ipactl restart'.

Now you should call

  • 'kinit admin' again, because the new TGT will now contain the PAC data
  • the following two steps are not needed if FreeIPA 3.0beta2 or a newer version is used:
    • 'ipa passwd admin', to create the needed data so that the admin account can be use in NTLM authentication
    • if the password change fails with 'Constraint violation: Too soon to change password' you can wait one hour or change the password policy with 'ipa pwpolicy-mod --minlife=0'

Some sanity checks

The following commands can be used to check that smbd and winbindd are basically working:

  • 'smbclient -L server.ipa-domain -k'
  • 'wbinfo --online-status'

Populating ipaNTSecurityIdentifier (SID) for existing users and groups

After running ipa-adtrust-install new users and groups will automatically get the needed attributes and objectclasses to be used with trust. This mainly means the SID which is stored in the ipaNTSecurityIdentifier LDAP attribute.

If an existing IPA installation is upgrade a SID must be assigned to existing users and groups. A directory server task was added for this purpose. Since this task can cause some replication traffic in setups with multiple IPA servers and many users and groups, is is not run automatically during the update or while running ipa-adtrust-install. To start the task the following LDIF file

 dn: cn=sidgen,cn=ipa-sidgen-task,cn=tasks,cn=config
 changetype: add
 objectClass: top
 objectClass: extensibleObject
 cn: sidgen
 nsslapd-basedn: dc=YOUR,dc=BASEDN 
 delay: 0

must be loaded with

ldapmodify -H ldapi://%2fvar%2frun%2fslapd-YOUR-REALM.socket -f ipa-sidgen-task-start.ldif

as root or with directory manager credentials. There are two parameters, nsslapd-basedn sould be set to your base DN. delay is the time between two modifications in nano seconds. It can be used to spread the replication traffic over a longer period of time.

In the logs a message like

sidgen_task_thread - [file ipa_sidgen_task.c, line 191]: Sidgen task starts ...

is shown when the task starts and

sidgen_task_thread - [file ipa_sidgen_task.c, line 196]: Sidgen task finished [0].

when the task finished successfully.

Create a trust to an AD domain

Currently it is not possible to create a trust from the AD side, because AD expect a directory server with an AD layout on the other side. We have to investigate further what can be done to let AD create a trust with FreeIPA. But since there are no plans to create a directory structure similar to AD it might be possible that a trust can only be created from the FreeIPA side.

The following command can be used to create a trust:

ipa trust-add --type=ad ad.domain --admin Administrator --password

You will be asked for the password of the AD Administrator.

Check out this video to see the whole process of setting up a trust, incuding a quick test that it is working (Note: the video was taken before we changed the command format from "ipa trust-add-ad" to "ipa trust-add --type=ad", the latter is the correct command now).

Testing cross-realm Kerberos configuration

If you request a TGT for a FreeIPA user with

kinit ipauser@IPA.TEST

You should be able to request service tickets for services form the FreeIPA domain:

kvno host/other-host.ipa.test@IPA.TEST

and also for services from the AD domain

kvno cifs/ad-dom-member.ad.test@AD.TEST

If you successful request a service ticket from the AD domain you should also find a cross-realm TGT 'krbtgt/AD.TEST@IPA.TEST'.

Validating the trust from the Windows side

With recent versions of the samba4 package (newer than 2011-12-21) it is possible to validate the trust from the windows side. To do this open the 'Active Directory Domains and Trusts' tool. Open the Properties of your local domain, jump to the Trust tab and open the properties of the FreeIPA trusted domain. Now you can hit the validate button. After a few second you will be asked if you want to validate the incoming trust as well. For the you have to use the admin user and must provide the admin password.

Configure IPA client

To allow sssd to look for users in trusted domains

subdomains_provider = ipa

has to be added to the domain section in sssd.conf. Additionally you might want to add 'subdomain_homedir = /home/%d/%u' or similar to define home directories for users from trusted domains.

To evaluate data from the PAC (http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-brezak-win2k-krb-authz-01) the PAC responder must be started as well. To do this add 'pac' to the services list to the sssd section in sssd.conf, e.g.

services = nss, pam, ssh, pac

Currently the PAC is mainly used to add the remote user to additional groups of the IPA domain.

Allowing individual access with .k5login

If only a few users from a trusted domain shall be allowed to access the client or if users from the trusted domain shall access the client as a user from the IPA domain a .k5login (please note the dot as the first character of the name) file can be used. For the first case the Kerberos principal name of the user from the trusted domain (username@TRUSTED.DOMAIN) has to be put into the .k5login file in the home directory of the trusted user. For the second case the same content has to be put into the .k5login file in the home directory of the IPA user.

Allowing global access for a trusted domain

If all users from a trusted domain should be allowed to access the client the .k5login approach will not scale. Here the following line can be added to the section for the local realm in /etc/krb5.conf

  auth_to_local = RULE:[1:$1@$0](^.*@TRUSTED.DOMAIN$)s/@TRUSTED.DOMAIN/@trusted.domain/
  auth_to_local = DEFAULT

See 'info krb5-admin "Configuration Files" "krb5.conf" "realms (krb5.conf)"' for more details and examples for auth_to_local.

Testing with ssh

A GSSAPI aware Windows ssh client must be installed on the windows server. I used the putty from Quest http://rc.quest.com/topics/putty/, but recently GSSAPI support was also added to the "standard" putty http://www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/~sgtatham/putty/download.html. If you now log on to the windows server as the test use abc and use putty to connect with GSSAPI to the FreeIPA server it should just work without asking for a password.

Configuring Putty for SSO

  1. In Connection - Data, set Auto-login username to "user@ad.realm". Be cautious, this field is case sensitive. To configure Administrator user in AD domain ad.test, configure the field to Administrator@ad.test
  2. In Connection - SSH - Auth - GSSAPI, make sure that Allow GSSAPI credential delegation checkbox is checked
  3. In Session, set your FreeIPA managed machine Host name, save the session and connect

Adding remote users to IPA groups

Users of trusted domains can be added to groups of the IPA domain in two steps. First an "external" group has to be created to hold the identifiers of remote objects. Then is group can be added to a group of the IPA domain.

Creating an external group and adding objects

To create an external group the '--external' option was added to 'ipa group-add'

ipa group-add --desc="External test group" --external ext_test

To add remote objects to the external group from the command line the SID of the object must be known:

ipa group-add-member ext_test --external S-1-5-21-2324474119-2878384365-2573063092-513

Adding an external group to an IPA group

External groups can a added like local groups to other groups:

ipa group-add-member --groups=ext_test local_ipa_group

If now the the KDC receives a TGS request from a trusted domain, i.e a user from the trusted domain wants to access a service from the IPA domain, it will extract all SIDs from the PAC in the request. If one or more of these SIDs are members of external groups and the external groups are members of IPA groups the SIDs of the IPA groups will be added to the PAC before sending the service ticket back.

The remote machine will now send the service ticket to the IPA client where the requested service is running. If the PAC responder is configured on this client (see Configure IPA client) the remote user is added to IPA groups on the client.

FreeIPA user on Windows Desktop

An FreeIPA user can log in to a Windows Desktop from the trusted domain. The domain part of the user name must be the REALM of the IPA domain, e.g. 'IPA.TEST\ipauser'.

Testing File-Server (CIFS) access

Please note, although the following step can be done on the IPA server as on any IPA client, it is not recommended to run a file-serve in the IPA server.

Server side (IPA client)

One or more share have to be created in the samba configuration by either adding them to /etc/smb.conf or by using 'net conf addshare' for registry based configurations. (To add a share on the IPA server for quick testing use 'net conf addshare test /tmp', please do not forget to call 'net conf delshare test' after testing).

Since samba isn't very flexible in searching for local user names SSSD has to be configured to use fully qualified names like SHORTDOMAINNAME\username instead of the default username@LONG.DOMAIN.NAME. The following regular expression must be added to the appropriate domain section or to the sssd section

re_expression = (?P<domain>[^\\]*?)\\?(?P<name>[^\\]+$)

The following regular expression can be used to support both types of fully qualified names at the same time

re_expression = (((?P<domain>[^\\]+)\\(?P<name>.+$))|((?P<name>[^@]+)@(?P<domain>.+$))|(^(?P<name>[^@\\]+)$))

Please note that a very recent version of sssd is needed (currently only available in the ipa-devel repository) to allow the short (NetBIOS) domain names to be used.

Client side (Windows)

To access the share on the IPA client either

net use * \\ipa.client\sharename

or use 'Map network drive...' available e.g. with a right-click on the Computer object in the Windows explorer.


Section listing quick gotchas to help you setup a trust.

Q1> Why do I get the following error when running ipa trust-add --type=ad

"ipa: ERROR: Cannot find specified domain or server name"

A: Because your IPA server can't see the keberos or LDAP records that tell it where the target DC is. To troubleshoot which records your system is having an issue with. Add the following log level = 11 to /usr/share/ipa/smb.conf.empty. When you check /var/log/httpd/error_log you will see which SVR records IPA is having an issue resolving.

If per chance your records are fine. It could be the case you just edited your /etc/resolv.conf file and simply restarting the IPA stack will resolve your issue. (restart using ipactl restart )