V4/Migrating existing environments to Trust
- 1 Overview
- 2 Use Cases
- 3 Design
- 4 Implementation
- 5 Feature Management
- 6 Updates and Upgrades
- 7 How to Test
When FreeIPA server is configured with Winsync synchronization with Active Directory, all users are copied to FreeIPA server with generated POSIX attributes (e.g. login name, UID, GID, shell...). Such architecture has several downsides, when compared to infrastructure based on Cross-Realm Trusts. However, it was very difficult to migrate to it given synchronized AD users already had POSIX attributes generated.
New ID Views mechanism allows configuring POSIX attributes for AD users and thus allows admin to remove such user entity from FreeIPA Directory Server, leverage Trusts and only define the default (or per host group) user (or group) POSIX attributes.
Store POSIX attributes and SSH keys for AD users
This capability is useful both for migration from Winsync or in a situation when Linux admins would like to manually define POSIX attributes for AD users, but AD policy do not allow it.
Migration from the Sync to the Trust solution
Utilize ID Views interface to configure needed POSIX attributes for existing users synchronized with Winsync and move them back to AD. The mechanism follows simple procedure:
- Select a user/group entry to be migrated
- Create a default or host-based ID View override specifying previously used UID or other tools
- Backup migrated user/group
- Delete user/group original entry
Per hostgroup override of FreeIPA user POSIX attributes
Use ID Views mechanism to override FreeIPA user POSIX attributes on specified servers that may not yet be using the unified domain ones. This option is useful for example for users migrated from NIS.
A new concept of ID Views is introduced. Every ID View is a collection of user and group overrides that applies to specified hosts or as a default to all hosts. Each override is bound to an AD or IPA user.
Following list of user attributes can be overridden in an ID View:
- uid: user login name
- uidNumber: user UID number
- gidNumber: user GID number
- loginShell: user login shell
- gecos: user GECOS
- homeDirectory: user home directory
- ipaSshPubkey: user SSH public key(s)
Following list of group attributes can be overridden in an ID View:
- cn: group name
- gidNumber: group GID number
In an environment with a Trust, the SSSD on the FreeIPA server reads the data from AD and immediately apply the overrides from the default view which are defined in the FreeIPA LDAP tree. The extdom plugin returns this data directly to clients while the compat tree reads the data from SSSD and apply the overrides from another view if needed for the client. Clients using the extdom plugin have to read client specific view data on their own from the FreeIPA LDAP tree and apply them on their own.
ID ranges are used in FreeIPA to avoid collisions of POSIX IDs from different domains especially if the POSIX IDs are algorithmically generated. Although it would be possible to create a special range type for the POSIX IDs used in ID Views, they are not needed. The main reason is that we have to allow overlaps with all other kind of ID ranges. E.g. AD user which where created in the FreeIPA Directory Server tree by the winsync solution have POSIX IDs from the same ID range as IPA users. If we want to migrate them to the trust solution we would have to add those POSIX ID in the default view.
Another reason is that the POSIX IDs in the views are managed manually on the FreeIPA side and conflicts and collisions can easily be fixed by changing the offending POSIX ID. The requirement that the POSIX IDs used in the views must match given ranges would make this feature more cumbersome to use without adding additional protection.
attributeTypes: (2.16.840.1.113718.104.22.168.62 NAME 'ipaAnchorUUID' DESC 'Unique Anchor Identifier' EQUALITY caseIgnoreMatch ORDERING caseIgnoreOrderingMatch SYNTAX 22.214.171.124.4.1.14126.96.36.199.15 SINGLE-VALUE X-ORIGIN 'IPA v4') attributeTypes: (2.16.840.1.1137188.8.131.52.63 NAME 'ipaOriginalUid' DESC 'Original UID of overriden user' EQUALITY caseIgnoreMatch ORDERING caseIgnoreOrderingMatch SYNTAX 184.108.40.206.4.1.14220.127.116.11.15 SINGLE-VALUE X-ORIGIN 'IPA v4') objectClasses: (2.16.840.1.113718.104.22.168.29 NAME 'ipaIDView' SUP nsContainer STRUCTURAL MAY ( description ) X-ORIGIN 'IPA v4' ) objectClasses: (2.16.840.1.113722.214.171.124.30 NAME 'ipaOverrideAnchor' SUP top STRUCTURAL MUST ( ipaAnchorUUID ) MAY ( description ) X-ORIGIN 'IPA v4' ) objectClasses: (2.16.840.1.1137126.96.36.199.31 NAME 'ipaUserOverride' DESC 'Override for User Attributes' SUP ipaOverrideAnchor STRUCTURAL MAY ( uid $ uidNumber $ gidNumber $ homeDirectory $ loginShell $ gecos $ ipaOriginalUid ) X-ORIGIN 'IPA v4' ) objectClasses: (2.16.840.1.1137188.8.131.52.32 NAME 'ipaGroupOverride' DESC 'Override for Group Attributes' SUP ipaOverrideAnchor STRUCTURAL MAY ( gidNumber $ cn ) X-ORIGIN 'IPA v4' ) objectClasses: (2.16.840.1.1137184.108.40.206.34 NAME 'ipaOverrideTarget' SUP top STRUCTURAL MUST ( ipaAnchorUUID ) X-ORIGIN 'IPA v4' )
ID Views will be stored in containers below cn=views,cn=accounts,$SUFFIX with containers for users and groups. The objectclasses look similar to posixAccount and posixGroup objectclasses but with only optional (MAY) attributes.
As view will be applied on the client side so the older clients using the extdom plugin only get the default view. If they need a different view SSSD has to be updated to a version with view support or the client must use the compat tree.
On the server side we have to modify SSSD running in IPA server mode as well and the slapi-nis plugin for the compat tree.
On the SSSD side the override is done as late as possible. The AD users and group are looked up via the extdom plugin which return only the default view for any client. SSSD on the client will check which view the client should apply and load the overrides for the given view separately.
SSSD IPA backend
On startup the IPA backend has to look up the host entry of the client on the IPA server and determine the view for the client and save this information to the cache. If there is no entry the default view is assumed. If the view changes all old override value should be deleted and the cached user and group entries should be marked expired to force a new lookup. If the new view is the default view the original data can be kept and must not be marked expired.
If there is a view other than the default view assigned to the client after looking up the AD user with the extdom plugin it has to be checked if there are overrides available for the requested object. The override values must be written to the cache as well. If has to be decided if they should be saved together with the requested object or as separate objects.
It might be a good idea to safe the override data of the views in separate objects, maybe even in a separated tree and add DN attributes to the original object and the override data to link both together. With this is it easy to invalidate/expired the override value and the original data independently, e.g. if the view changes. Additionally if the client has the default view the cache layout does not change and requests can be processed as it is done now. Only if the client has a different view the responders have to check if the original object has an attribute which points to an override object and apply the needed changes. The main goal is that the responders do not need to know any details about how the views work. They only need to know if there is an object with override data or not and how to apply them.
When looking up users and groups on a client with a different view than the default view, the views has to be checked first. If a matching entry was found for the given name or ID the SID has to be extracted from the reference attribute. With the SID the related object is requested via the extdom plugin. Finally override data and the original object must be saved in the cache. If no override was found for the searched object it will be resolved by the extdom plugin as usual, but additionally after retrieving the original data it has to be checked with the help of the SID if there is an override for the object. This e.g. is necessary to cover cases where the object is looked up by the name, but only the IDs are overridden.
SSSD responders (NSS, PAM, InfoPipe and others)
If there are override values available for a requested object the responders must apply the overrides before returning the data to the clients.
When processing a request on a client which does not use the default view the corresponding override values must be checked first before looking at the original values. If a matching override value was found the request will continue with the corresponding original object and only in the end before the data is returned to the client the overrides are applied. (This is the same scheme used for the space replacement feature)
For this new sysdb calls to look up users and groups should be added which replace the current sysdb calls used at the entry points of the providers. Since there are already quite a number of sysdb calls for user and group lookups it is acceptable to add new ones and simplify the sysdb interface in a different project. Besides trying to find a corresponding view first this new calls should also fold the view data into the attributes of the original object by adding the view attributes with e.g. a prefix 'overide'. This will help to reduce additional cache lookup later. It has to be note that for group related lookup (getgr*, initgroups) the results contain list of group members or group the user is a member of where the overrides has to be applied as well. Here the override data should be added in a similar fashion with a 'override' prefix. With this all processing can be done with the original data and the overrides will only be applied when generating the responses to the clients without additional cache lookups. Finally the new calls should return a flag if overrides were found for the object which would help to speed up generating the responses.
It would be useful if the main responder context has flag if the host has a view at all and it is different from the default view. This will help to speed up operations if no overrides have to be applied at all, e.g. on the IPA server or classic LDAP setups. At startup the backends which support views (currently only IPA) should check if the host belongs to a different view and write the name as an attribute to e.g. cn=views,cn=sysdb. The actual override data can be added later below. The responder can than check if cn=views,cn=sysdb and has a viewName attribute set. Only in this case view processing is needed. This flag can be passed to the new sysdb calls to tell them if they could bypass the override lookups or not.
SSSD (IPA server mode)
The main purpose of the IPA server mode of SSSD is to look up the users and groups from the trusted domains so that they are available for standard POSIX calls like getpwnam().
In IPA server mode SSSD does not have to look up the view because IPA server will always and only have the default view.
In contrast to SSSD running on a client SSSD on the server has to apply the default view explicitly because it reads the data directly from AD, i.e. the overrides have to be applied before writing the data to the cache. The original data can be saved in attributes with e.g. a prefix 'ADOriginal' . SSSD on a client will read the data from the extdom plugin where the default view is already applied.
The following should be noted here:
- all IPA servers and replicas are hardcoded to the default view, it is not possible to assign a different view to them
- all other views are applied on top of the default view:
- if the default view e.g. overrides the uidNumber attribute from AD the original value from AD is _not_ available to any other view
- if an override value is changed in the default view and not overridden by e.g. view xyz the change in the default view will be visible on call clients assigned to the xyz view as well.
SSSD Cache layout
The cached entry of an AD object on IPA clients and servers will contain both the original AD data and the override value from the default view. As show in the following figure.
The green lines indicate the unmodified data from AD, the red ones those attributes where an override value exists in the default view and the blue line the override values.
As shown in the figure the overrides from the default view are already applied in the cached entry, i.e. the default attributes for name, UID and GID number, gecos, shell and home-directory already contain the override values, if any, and the original values from AD are available in attributes with the same name but the 'originalAD' prefix (the prefix can be changed to some other more sensible value, but no collisions are expected because SSSD cache attributes are mapped).
In contrast to store the override data of the default view separately in the SSSD cache this scheme has to following advantages:
- for the most common use cases like user and group lookups, no additional processing is needed, because the view is already applied.
- on IPA client with a different view than the default view only the other view has to be applied on top of the default view and not both the other and the default view on top of the original AD data
- AD objects with the default view are equivalent to IPA objects. This becomes important when we introduce views and overrides for IPA objects as well because for IPA objects there will be no overrides in the default view, because the IPA objects are the default view be definition. Saving the default view separately in the SSSD cache would lead to different code paths for IPA and AD objects. With this scheme IPA and AD obejcts can be handled in the same way both for the default view or an alternative view.
(Please note, I'm currently working on figures for the client case and a different view and the case where the name is overriden, here the nameAlias will contain the original fully qualified AD name and the un-qualified override name to allow searches with those names as well).
slapi-nis plugin/compat tree
The compat tree offers a simplified LDAP tree with user and group data for legacy clients. No data for this tree is stored on disk but it is always created on the fly. It has to be noted that legacy clients might be one of the major users of the user-views because chances are that they were attached to the legacy systems with legacy ID management which should be replaced by IPA.
In contrast to the extdom plugin it is not possible to determine the client based on the DN because connection might be anonymous. The Slapi_PBlock contains the IP address of the client in SLAPI_CONN_CLIENTNETADDR. Finding the matching client object in the IPA tree requires a reverse-DNS lookup which is unreliable.
Instead of relying on bound user information, slapi-nis will use base DN. A view-specific base DN will look like cn=myview,cn=views,cn=compat,$SUFFIX. View will be detected and base DN will be corrected to substract cn=myview,cn=views. A search then will happen against normal compat tree and resulted entries will be subjected to processing phase during which overrides from the selected view will be applied. As final step, DNs of the resulted entries will be rewritten to include cn=myview,cn=views.
Note that slapi-nis will apply only a host-specific view. For IPA users and groups the default values will come from the primary tree, so only host-specific view is required anyway. For AD objects default view will be 'Default Trust View', and it will be applied by SSSD running in the server mode on IPA master. Once slapi-nis retrieved these objects from SSSD, they further will be amended taking into account the host-specific view.
In this image both views have override value for the AD object A hence both uidNumber and gidNumber are replaced after the override of view xyz is applied.
In this example there is only a override in the default view defined for AD object A. The extdom plugin or the compat tree will forward the data return by SSSD unmodified when view xyz is requested because there are no override values for AD object A in this view.
On this figure there is no override in the default view defined for the AD object A. SSSD will return the data from AD unmodified and the extdom plugin or the compat tree will override the gidNumber if view xyz is requested for the AD object A.
In order to map original objects and overrides, a slapi-nis configuration produced by IPA will include specific attribue ipaAnchorUUID and objectclass ipaOverrideTarget. The value of ipaAnchorUUID will be value of ipaUniqueID prefixed by :IPA:$DOMAIN: for IPA users and groups, and value of AD object's SID prefixed with :SID: for AD objects. Resulting value of ipaAnchorUUID thus correspond to the RDN value of the override entry, allowing easy match between the two.
However, groups in the compat tree do not contain member attribute with DN to original entries. Instead, groups have memberUid attribute which contains values of 'uid' attribute of original members of the group, flattened for nested groups. This means memberUid attribute requires additional processing and there is no way to build ipaAnchorUUID value for them. Instead, for each user override IPA framework will maintain ipaOriginalUid value, containing original 'uid' attribute's value.
When group memberUid attribute is processed, slapi-nis will go over each value and will search an override which has the same value in ipaOriginalUid field (in the current view). If override with the ipaOriginalUid value exists, the override's 'uid' attribute's value is used to replace original memberUid value. Otherwise original memberUid value is copied over. This approach ensures memberUid values are correct with regards to the overrides of the current view.
A page to list all view and a page to change the attributes of the view object are needed (see CLI section below for details).
Management of the overrides
Default Trust View should prevent adding IPA users' and groups' overrides, i.e. only AD users overrides can be added to Default Trust View.
Additionally, Default Trust View itself should be protected from deletion.
Views must be added, displayed, modified and deleted. Imo the object for the default view does not need any changes and should not be deleted, so the tool can reject any attempt to change the default view.
The ipa host-* commands must be able to set/modify/delete the view for an IPA host.
Management of the overrides
It must be possible to add, display, modify and delete an override object for any trusted user or group in any view.
Since user and groups have different attributes there should be a command family for user and another one for groups. It should be possible to identify the trusted object by its fully qualified name or by its SID.
The find and show operations should take the fully qualified name or SID as an argument and should display the overrides found in any view if not a specific view is given by an option.
Currently implemented commands:
|idview-add||Add a new ID View.|
|idview-apply||Applies ID View to specified hosts or current members of specified hostgroups. If any other ID View is applied to the host, it is overriden.|
|idview-del||Delete an ID View.|
|idview-find||Search for an ID View.|
|idview-mod||Modify an ID View.|
|idview-show||Display information about an ID View.|
|idview-unapply||Clears ID View from specified hosts or current members of specified hostgroups.|
|idoverridegroup-add||Add a new Group ID override.|
|idoverridegroup-del||Delete an Group ID override.|
|idoverridegroup-find||Search for an Group ID override.|
|idoverridegroup-mod||Modify an Group ID override.|
|idoverridegroup-show||Display information about an Group ID override.|
|idoverrideuser-add||Add a new User ID override.|
|idoverrideuser-del||Delete an User ID override.|
|idoverrideuser-find||Search for an User ID override.|
|idoverrideuser-mod||Modify an User ID override.|
|idoverrideuser-show||Display information about an User ID override.|
Feature is activated during ipa-adtrust-install given it mostly targets trusted users. The existence of the view container cn=views,cn=accounts,$SUFFIX is used as an indicator if the ID Views are enabled or not.
Updates and Upgrades
Since ID views are not enabled by default only the new schema entries must be added during updates.
How to Test
You should end up with working trust:
------------------------------------------------------------------------ Added Active Directory trust for realm "tbad.idm.lab.eng.brq.redhat.com" ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Realm name: tbad.idm.lab.eng.brq.redhat.com Domain NetBIOS name: TBAD Domain Security Identifier: S-1-5-21-2997650941-1802118864-3094776726 SID blacklist incoming: S-1-5-20, S-1-5-3, S-1-5-2, S-1-5-1, S-1-5-7, S-1-5-6, S-1-5-5, S-1-5-4, S-1-5-9, S-1-5-8, S-1-5-17, S-1-5-16, S-1-5-15, S-1-5-14, S-1-5-13, S-1-5-12, S-1-5-11, S-1-5-10, S-1-3, S-1-2, S-1-1, S-1-0, S-1-5-19, S-1-5-18 SID blacklist outgoing: S-1-5-20, S-1-5-3, S-1-5-2, S-1-5-1, S-1-5-7, S-1-5-6, S-1-5-5, S-1-5-4, S-1-5-9, S-1-5-8, S-1-5-17, S-1-5-16, S-1-5-15, S-1-5-14, S-1-5-13, S-1-5-12, S-1-5-11, S-1-5-10, S-1-3, S-1-2, S-1-1, S-1-0, S-1-5-19, S-1-5-18 Trust direction: Two-way trust Trust type: Active Directory domain Trust status: Established and verified
After the trust has been establish, pick an AD existing user for testing, or create a new one. We will use
Check that the user UID, GID and group membership is returned correctly:
[tbabej@vm-124 labtool]$ id firstname.lastname@example.org uid=1218201156(email@example.com) gid=1218201156(firstname.lastname@example.org) groups=1218201156(email@example.com),1218201425(test firstname.lastname@example.org),1218200513(domain email@example.com)
Use Case: Store POSIX attributes and SSH keys for AD users using Default Trust View
Now, we can try to override a attribute for this testing user. We will use the 'Default Trust View', which is always applied for AD users and can only contain overrides for AD users and groups. Let's change the UID of the
testuser to 5555.
[tbabej@vm-124 labtool]$ ipa idoverrideuser-add 'Default Trust View' firstname.lastname@example.org --uid 5555 ----------------------------------------------------------------- Added User ID override "email@example.com" ----------------------------------------------------------------- Anchor to override: firstname.lastname@example.org UID: 5555
Let's now check that the user has override UID value.
[tbabej@vm-124 labtool]$ sudo systemctl restart sssd [tbabej@vm-124 labtool]$ id email@example.com uid=5555(firstname.lastname@example.org) gid=1218201156(email@example.com) groups=1218201156(firstname.lastname@example.org),1218201425(test email@example.com),1218200513(domain firstname.lastname@example.org)
In a similiar way, you can override GID, or other attributes, see
ipa idoverrideuser-add --help.
Use Case: Store POSIX attributes and SSH keys for AD users using host-specific ID View
For host-specific views, we cannot use Default Trust View, since that one is not host specific, it is always applied. We add a new ID view using the
[tbabej@vm-124 ~]$ ipa idview-add testview --desc "Our new host specific view" ------------------------ Added ID View "testview" ------------------------ ID View Name: testview Description: Our new host specific view
Having created a host specific view, we need to add a ID override to it. This works the same way as with Default Trust View. Suppose we want to override UID of our
testuser to 6666.
[tbabej@vm-124 ~]$ ipa idoverrideuser-add testview email@example.com --uid 6666 ----------------------------------------------------------------- Added User ID override "firstname.lastname@example.org" ----------------------------------------------------------------- Anchor to override: email@example.com UID: 6666
Now we're ready to apply the view to a specific host. The
ipa idview-apply command is used for this purpose. The host can be specified either via --hosts option or --hostgroups option. Please note that --hostgroups option is just a helper, ID view is never associated with the hostgroup itself, only with particular hosts. If you pass hostgroup to the idview-apply command, the members of hostgroup are expanded internally, and host is applied to each of them.
[tbabej@vm-124 ~]$ ipa idview-apply testview --hosts vm-057.dom124.tbad.idm.lab.eng.brq.redhat.com -------------------------- Applied ID View "testview" -------------------------- hosts: vm-057.dom124.tbad.idm.lab.eng.brq.redhat.com --------------------------------------------- Number of hosts the ID View was applied to: 1 ---------------------------------------------
We can check that our AD
testuser is overriden in a different way on our client, than on the server:
[tbabej@vm-057 labtool]$ id firstname.lastname@example.org uid=6666(email@example.com) gid=5555(firstname.lastname@example.org) groups=5555(email@example.com),1218201425(test firstname.lastname@example.org)
Use Case: Migration from the Sync to the Trust solution
To migrate from winsync to trusts you will need to take following steps:
1. Create a trust with the synced domain 2. For all users that have been synced, you need to: a. create a ID override in "Default Trust View" for the synced user to preserve IPA generated UID and GID b. delete the sync agreement c. delete the synced user